20 Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Food Recipes (And Some Myths)

Homemade dog food has its pros and cons. This can be a great nutritional choice for dogs, but only when done right. If done incorrectly, however, feeding a dog an unbalanced homemade diet will negatively impact your pet’s health.

What is a Homemade Dog Food Diet?

Homemade dog food is a term used for food that is prepared and cooked for dogs at home by pet owners using the same “human food” ingredients that we use in our own diets. Dogs fed a homemade dog food diet can avoid eating processed commercial dog food brands like dry kibble, dehydrated dog foods or canned wet dog food.

There are many reasons why pet owners choose to feed homemade dog food recipes:

• Fear of too frequent recalls of commercial pet foods
• Unique health needs of ailing dogs
• More appetizing meals for picky dogs that refuse to eat
• Dogs with allergies to numerous ingredients
• A desire for improved ingredient quality or better quality control
• Knowing exactly what goes into every single one of your dog’s meals

With so much controversy surrounding the pet food industry, it’s no wonder that more and more dog owners are shying away from commercial dog food brands and switching to using homemade dog food recipes to feed their canines a healthy meal.

What Homemade Dog Food Diets Exist?

There are three popular ways to go about feeding your pet a homemade dog food diet. The most popular homemade diets for dogs are so-called “raw diets” where the focus is on providing unprocessed raw meats and, depending on the diet, fruits and veggies.

1. The BARF Diet – based on “ancestral” diet and the idea that dogs are omnivores, it’s focused on unprocessed and “biologically appropriate” foods for dogs. Those include meat, bones, organs, fruits, vegetables and supplements.

2. The Prey Model Raw (PMR) Diet – the PMR diet is animal-exclusive, and attempts to emulate what dogs would eat in the wild (what wolves eat) – whole prey. It includes meat, bones, organs, feathers, etc. There are no fruits or vegetables.

3. The DIY Homemade Dog Food Diet – a whatever works type of diet, where no specific rules apply other than whatever works for the dog and provides the nutrition needed without inclusion or exclusion of specific foods. Unlike the raw models, it can include both cooked and uncooked foods, and supplements.

Here at Top Dog Tips, we’re big fans of the third homemade diet because it allows to design recipes and meals that would 100% fit a dog’s nutritional needs without any unreasonable rules or restrictions. See our Dog Food Recipes section for more on this.

The Benefits of DIY Homemade Dog Food Recipes

When they’re nutritionally balanced and adjusted to an individual dog’s needs, homemade dog food recipes can be exceptionally beneficial for many reasons. To accomplish this, a pet owner would need to work with a veterinarian or a certified canine nutritionist.

Health issues like kidney, liver or heart disease can all be managed through veterinary care and a properly selected homemade dog food diet with ingredients that are good for such conditions. Homemade food can be beneficial for puppies, adult and senior dogs.

No matter what your pet’s overall health and wellness, homemade dog food can provide them with an enticing meal that will benefit a dog’s body. Feeding a homemade diet can benefit pet owners, too. Some advantages of feeding homemade dog food are below.

1. Regulation of Pet Food Quality

Pet food recalls are quite prevalent these days, which makes dog owners worry about the quality and safety of dog foods they feed their canines.

Making homemade dog food for your pet allows you to regulate what foods go into his diet, much more so than going with commercial dog food brands.

I am not only talking about meat versus byproduct, but also which cuts of meat, where that meat came from and the quality of the meat overall.

2. No Filler Ingredients in Homemade Foods

Commercial pet foods bulk up their products with cheap filler ingredients that lack nutritional value. This allows for the creation of large amounts of food for a reduced cost.

Ingredients that are not nutritionally valuable, however, tend to pass through your dog’s system and create more waste.

It is also worth noting that filler ingredients in dog foods are often allergy-causing ingredients. Homemade dog food recipes allow you to optimize the nutritional value of the food you’re feeding and eliminate unnecessary fillers and potential allergens.

3. Increased Variety in the Diet

Feeding a commercial dog food diet often result in feeding the same variety of kibble for at least a month at a time (think one 30 lb bag of kibble). This lack of variation is boring for your dog, but it is also limiting in terms of nutritional value.

Homemade dog food recipes allow you to regularly vary the ingredients of your pup’s meals to offer a wider range of nutrients. Just like us, the more varied the nutrients your dog receives from their diet, the healthier they will be.

4. Homemade Dog Food Diet May Provide Better Nutrition

Despite ingredient labels offering up information, commercial dog foods are often quite cryptic in terms of specifics (for example, “meat byproduct”). This leaves you feeding your dog mysterious ingredients or in the very least, artificial ingredients.

Choosing to feed homemade dog food recipes allows you to incorporate more whole foods and healthy ingredients into Fido’s diet. Additionally, you can avoid feeding your dog questionable ingredients like by-products.

5. Homemade Dog Foods Are Fresh, Not Preserved

Where even the best quality dog foods incorporate artificial preservatives and added salts to keep them fresh, homemade dog food does not.

These preservatives can exacerbate existing health conditions, like heart disease, as well as contribute to general poor health.

Just as it is better for humans to eat fewer preservatives and more fresh food, it is healthier for dogs as well.

6. No More Waste (Or Less of It)

Home cooking dog food allows you the opportunity to use dog-friendly leftovers from human meals. This means less waste and less cost for your household.

You can plan your families meals – both human and canine – ahead of time and save money by buying protein sources, fruits and vegetables in bulk.

7. Homemade Dog Food Can Be Cheaper (Sometimes)

Some prescription dog foods or unique in their nutritional composition and require high manufacturing costs, such as protein based dog foods. Thus, they are often extremely expensive for owners.

Depending on the type of commercial pet food your dog is eating, you may find that homemade dog food is a cheaper alternative for you. However, if your dog doesn’t require prescription dog foods, then a homemade diet may actually be more expensive.

8. Elimination of Allergens Through Home Cooking

When dogs have a sensitive stomach or some type of allergies, it is not always enough to simply choose a dog food without that allergen in it. It is possible that a dog food can be exposed to that allergen during manufacturing or contain another variant of that allergen, such as chicken fat versus chicken.

When making home cooked dog food, you can control exactly what ingredients go into your pet’s food and eliminate any trace of allergens.

You can work with your veterinarian or a canine nutritionist to eliminate the allergens in homemade dog food recipes and substitute healthy alternatives.

The Disadvantages of Homemade Dog Food

There are plenty of great benefits to feeding a homemade dog food diet, but is it all good? Unfortunately, it’s not. There are a few drawbacks to cooking homemade pet food.

9. Lack of Nutritional Balance in Some Home Diets

It is crucial, when making homemade dog food, that the correct supplements and vitamins are added to create optimal nutrition for your dog.

Many writers of homemade dog food recipes are not aware of these unique dietary needs and fail to incorporate the necessary supplements and vitamins. This results in health concerns, weight loss, and decreased energy.

To ensure that a dog food recipe is nutritionally rounded, always choose a recipe book that has been formulated or overseen by a canine nutritionist or veterinarian.

10. There Are Some Unsafe Ingredients to be Aware Of

Most dog owners are aware that there are certain human foods that are unsafe for dogs (chocolate, onions, raisins, grapes, etc.) Unfortunately, not all dog owners or authors of homemade dog food recipes are aware of all of these unsafe ingredients.

The best way to avoid cooking a dog food recipe that includes one of these foods is to utilize recipes formulated or overseen by a canine nutritionist or veterinarian. Additionally, familiarize yourself with the complete list of unsafe human foods for dogs.

11. Too Many or Not Enough Calories in Homemade Foods

Dog owners who feed commercially prepared dog foods simply read the back of their dog food bag and know roughly how much food their dog needs per day. Following homemade dog food recipes means you’re not provided with such concise nutritional information.

It is this lack of nutritional information that often results in underfeeding dogs or overfeeding dogs when beginning a homemade dog food diet.

This can be avoided by selecting homemade dog food recipes that do provide nutritional information or by calculating this information yourself with precision.

12. Homemade Dog Food Can Be Expensive (Sometimes)

Perhaps the biggest drawback to homemade dog food recipes is cost.

Unlike commercial dog foods which can be quite affordable, homemade dog food relies on more costly ingredients. You can sometimes still find good quality homemade dog food recipes and stick to a reasonable budget if you really want to.

For most, there is no getting around the additional expense of homemade dog food, but it can be limited in the following ways:

• Buy ingredients in bulk and freeze
• Use a vacuum sealer to keep extra food fresh in the fridge or freezer
• Select dog food recipes using seasonal ingredients or ingredients on sale
• Make substitutions for more expensive or harder to find ingredients
• Base your homemade dog food recipes on what you are eating for dinner that night and simply buy more and ration appropriately.

13. Cooking for Dogs Will Take Some of Your Time

Unlike commercial dog food, following homemade dog food recipes requires a considerable time commitment. Instead of simply scooping food into your dog’s bowl, you must measure, cook, portion, and store your dog’s food routinely. It’s a chore.

Homemade dog food can be time-consuming, but cooking in bulk and freezing your dog’s food for later can help to reduce your overall time in the kitchen.

14. Homemade Dog Food Can Be Inconvenient

While humans have plenty of choices for eating when they are traveling, dogs do not. Home cooking dog food is simply not convenient for anyone who travels frequently. Most boarding kennels are not accommodating when it comes to feeding home cooked food and traveling with a dog makes home cooked feeding even more difficult.

Most home cooking dog owners have to turn to commercial diets of some type when traveling since it is too inconvenient to home feed on the road.

6 Myths About Homemade Dog Food Recipes

As with everything in the pet industry, just because other pet owners say it does not make it true. Sadly, there are some who like to spread myths about everything from dog food to grooming, which can be dangerous. Here are some of the myths about homemade dog food recipes and the process of cooking for dogs that you need to be aware of:

15. Variety Trumps Supplements

Some dog owners who feed a homemade diet believe that if they include enough variety in their dog’s diet, they do not need to add any supplements to the food. This is simply untrue.

A dog’s nutritional needs are different to our own and while incorporating variety into a dog’s diet is important, it will not meet all of a dog’s needs nutritionally.

16. Multivitamins Make Cooked Meals Well-Balanced

Many dog owners who feed a home cooked diet think that they can make up for any nutritional imbalances in many homemade dog food recipes by throwing a multivitamin into the mix every day. This isn’t always true.

Depending on the meal a dog is eating, certain supplementation must be made and others left out. Adding in a “complete” multivitamin does not fix this issue, however, since they are not made to supplement home feeding.

While some vitamins and minerals in the supplement for can indeed help improve the nutritional structure of homemade dog foods, most multivitamins for dogs are made to supplement commercial diets which are already considered to be quite well balanced.

This means that your dog will still not receive certain vitamins and minerals from his diet that he really needs. Then, there’s also a question of bioavailability of these supplements.

17. Pick Ingredients Instead of Supplements

If for example, when a dog is lacking in calcium, many dog owners believe that they can supplement a meal with cottage cheese or yogurt to add this calcium.

However, it makes it very difficult to accurately calculate how much the dog needs and how much you’ll provide him through added foods.

Many of the nutrients that a dog requires supplementing are needed in higher concentrations than can be provided through ingredients like yogurt or cottage cheese. This means you may not be able to feed your dog enough calcium without added calories.

Sometimes supplements are better, and other times – not so.

18. More Vegetables is Better

Many people following homemade dog food recipes believe that adding more fruits and vegetables to a dog’s diet is always better because it adds more vitamins and varied nutrition. Unfortunately, dogs are not as omnivorous as some other animals.

This means that they thrive on a diet that is made up of primarily animal protein, and their digestive system is not made to handle large quantities of vegetables.

Adding large amounts of vegetables to a dog’s diet will not improve their health, rather it may cause digestive distress. Some fruits and vegetables are good for the dog, but excessive amount may do the opposite.

19. Brown Rice is Better than White Rice

The only difference between brown and white rice is their glycemic index, meaning brown rice may spike the insulin level slightly less than white rice. It’s not much healthier.

Furthermore, it is much more difficult for a dog’s digestive system to process brown rice than it is to process white rice. Additionally, if adding rice to a dog’s meal to help with tummy trouble, brown rice does not have the same binding qualities as white rice does.

20. A Well-Balanced Human Meal is Right for a Dog

Human beings are omnivores. We thrive on a diet that consists of protein, carbohydrates, and fats. These macronutrients are optimized to meet our needs in a well-balanced meal.

Dogs, however, are carnivorous scavengers depending on primarily animal protein, but able to process small quantities of processed grain, fruits, and vegetables.

The ratios of these macronutrients required by dogs are much different to the macronutrients required by humans, however, because dogs are not omnivores.

READ NEXT: 50 Best Homemade Dog Food Recipes

Want to share this?