Comparing Similar Dog Foods | How to Choose a Dog Food

January 13, 2023 Kar-Bay-Inc

Dry Dog Food 2 — Independent pet supply stores often have the best-informed, most helpful staff, who can help direct you to appropriate foods for your dog’s needs. We suggest buying from independent stores whenever possible (but understand that not everyone lives in a town with one or more of these!)

Many people (and even many veterinarians) believe that all foods that are labeled as “complete and balanced” contain approximately the same amounts and levels of nutrients. This presumes that pet food makers are all working to meet some sort of “recommended daily allowance” (RDA) of nutrients required by dogs – but it’s not true.

The RDA nutrient levels for humans were developed by the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Research Council/National Academy of Sciences. Vitamin, mineral, and macronutrient (fat, protein, carbohydrate) levels are expressed on our food packages as providing some percentage of the total amount of various nutrients that we need daily. But this isn’t how nutrient levels in pet foods are expressed.

The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) establishes the nutrient levels that legally constitute “complete and balanced” diets for our pets, and publishes the requirements for canine diets in a table – the “AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles.”

But, unlike the human RDAs with target levels of nutrients, the Dog Food Nutrient Profiles consist only of minimum values for all the nutrients required by dogs and maximum values for just a few nutrients. As long as a food meets the minimum nutrient values expressed in the profiles, and doesn’t exceed the maximum values, it can be labeled as “complete and balanced.”

Let’s say it another way: The foods on your pet store shelves may actually contain wildly varying levels of vitamins, minerals, and macronutrients, and yet all can call themselves “complete and balanced.”

All of the chicken- and rice-based foods below are labeled as “complete and balanced” diets for adult dogs; each purportedly meets the minimum nutritional standards for the “maintenance” of adult dogs. But we can’t possibly consider these foods as equivalent. We’ve listed the first 10 ingredients from their labels so you can compare the formulas. We’ve also positioned them in order of decreasing quality – from first to worst – in our opinion and according to our selection criteria.