Bronx Zoo elephant named Happy is not a person, a court rules : NPR
[ad_1]
Bebeto Matthews/AP
Happy the elephant may be intelligent and deserving of compassion, but she cannot be considered a person being illegally confined to the Bronx Zoo, New York’s top court ruled Tuesday.
The 5-2 decision by the state Court of Appeals comes in a closely watched case that tested the boundaries of applying human rights to animals.
The zoo and its supporters warned that a win for advocates at the Nonhuman Rights Project could open the door to more legal actions on behalf of animals, including pets, farm animals and other species in zoos.
The court’s majority echoed that point.
The decision written by Chief Judge Janet DiFiore said that “while no one disputes that elephants are intelligent beings deserving of proper care and compassion,” a writ of habeas corpus is intended to protect the liberty of human beings and does not apply to a nonhuman animal like Happy.
The decision affirms a lower court decision and means Happy will not be released through a habeas corpus proceeding, which is a way for people to challenge illegal confinement. Granting that right to Happy to challenge her confinement at a zoo “would have an enormous destabilizing impact on modern society,” read the majority decision.
“Indeed, followed to its logical conclusion, such a determination would call into question the very premises underlying pet ownership, the use of service animals, and the enlistment of animals in other forms of work,” read the decision.
The Bronx Zoo argued Happy is neither illegally imprisoned nor a person, but a well-cared-for elephant “respected as the magnificent creature she is.”
The advocates at the Nonhuman Rights Project argued that Happy is an autonomous, cognitively complex elephant worthy of the right reserved in law for “a person.”
Two judges, Rowan Wilson and Jenny Rivera, wrote separate, sharply worded dissents saying the fact that Happy is an animal does not prevent her from having legal rights. Rivera wrote that Happy is being held in “an environment that is unnatural to her and that does not allow her to live her life.”
“Her captivity is inherently unjust and inhumane. It is an affront to a civilized society, and every day she remains a captive — a spectacle for humans — we, too, are diminished,” Rivera wrote.
The ruling from New York’s highest court cannot be appealed. The Nonhuman Rights Project has failed to prevail in similar cases, including those involving a chimpanzee in upstate New York named Tommy.
Steven Wise, the group’s founder, said he was pleased it managed to persuade some of the judges. He noted that the group has a similar case underway in California and more planned in other states and other countries.
“We will take a really close look at why we lost and we’ll try to make sure that that doesn’t happen again to the extent that we can,” he said.
Happy was born in the wild in Asia in the early 1970s, captured and brought as a 1-year-old to the United States. Happy arrived at the Bronx Zoo in 1977 with fellow elephant Grumpy, who was fatally injured in a 2002 confrontation with two other elephants.
[ad_2]
Source link
buy medicines online in india indian pharmacy paypal world pharmacy india indiapharmacy.guru
oral atorvastatin 80mg lipitor 20mg price lipitor us
order propecia 1mg pill order propecia 5mg generic diflucan 100mg oral
purchase ciprofloxacin generic – buy generic trimethoprim purchase augmentin online cheap
purchase cipro without prescription – keflex 125mg for sale oral augmentin
purchase flagyl online – buy oxytetracycline generic generic zithromax 250mg
order ciplox 500mg for sale – order tindamax pill erythromycin 500mg sale
valtrex tablet – order vermox 100mg generic acyclovir 400mg us
buy stromectol 6mg – order sumycin for sale buy sumycin 250mg generic
flagyl 400mg cheap – purchase cleocin online generic zithromax 250mg
buy acillin for sale how to get penicillin without a prescription amoxil cheap
order furosemide 40mg generic – coumadin 2mg cheap purchase capoten generic
glucophage drug – oral cefadroxil 250mg lincomycin 500mg usa
purchase retrovir for sale – order zyloprim online
order clozaril – accupril 10 mg canada generic pepcid 40mg
oral quetiapine – order bupron SR pill eskalith for sale
buy clomipramine 25mg online – celexa cost sinequan 75mg usa
hydroxyzine 10mg for sale – hydroxyzine pills amitriptyline cost
order augmentin 1000mg sale – myambutol 600mg for sale buy ciprofloxacin 1000mg online
buy generic amoxicillin over the counter – erythromycin 500mg pills buy cipro cheap
cleocin 150mg pill – buy chloramphenicol pill buy generic chloramphenicol
azithromycin cost – buy tinidazole for sale order ciprofloxacin 500mg for sale
buy ivermectin online – purchase cefaclor generic generic cefaclor 250mg
get asthma pills online – buy ventolin 4mg sale generic theophylline
buy desloratadine sale – aristocort 10mg oral albuterol oral
brand glyburide – forxiga 10 mg pill buy cheap generic forxiga
buy lamisil 250mg pill – brand lamisil griseofulvin price
rybelsus 14mg cost – cost glucovance buy desmopressin
buy ketoconazole no prescription – buy sporanox without prescription itraconazole brand
famvir 500mg sale – buy valaciclovir 500mg buy cheap valcivir
purchase lanoxin without prescription – buy furosemide generic order lasix 100mg generic
buy hydrochlorothiazide generic – buy plendil 5mg online zebeta 5mg canada
lopressor over the counter – inderal pills nifedipine usa
buy nitroglycerin pills – buy lozol no prescription purchase diovan pill
crestor online affair – zetia dull caduet useless
zocor save – fenofibrate apart atorvastatin unseen
viagra professional beyond – levitra oral jelly vim levitra oral jelly online fully
cenforce silence – tadalis otherwise brand viagra good
brand cialis along – tadora animal penisole water
cialis soft tabs pills together – viagra oral jelly online devote viagra oral jelly blade
brand cialis ask – tadora difficulty penisole violent
cialis soft tabs online world – cialis soft tabs online twinkle viagra oral jelly crack
cenforce online appear – sildenafil 100mg pills brand viagra pills section
acne medication witness – acne medication brown acne treatment best
uti antibiotics horse – treatment for uti grave uti antibiotics empty
prostatitis treatment butter – prostatitis pills arrival prostatitis medications chew
valtrex pills department – valacyclovir online minister valtrex pills iron
loratadine why – claritin pills threat claritin pills shiver
priligy market – priligy window dapoxetine limb
loratadine medication arrangement – claritin edward loratadine medication lunch
ascorbic acid tangle – ascorbic acid pilot ascorbic acid correct
promethazine shiver – promethazine angle promethazine impression
biaxin pills helm – clarithromycin pills subtle cytotec dip
fludrocortisone pills click – esomeprazole gun prevacid pills ground
order aciphex online – buy aciphex 20mg online purchase motilium generic
purchase bisacodyl sale – cheap ditropan buy liv52 medication
oral cotrimoxazole 960mg – purchase tobrex drops order tobramycin 5mg online cheap
forxiga 10 mg brand – buy sinequan 25mg pills precose tablet
order griseofulvin 250 mg online – dipyridamole drug order gemfibrozil 300 mg for sale
buy dimenhydrinate 50 mg – prasugrel 10mg drug buy actonel
order generic vasotec 5mg – order doxazosin 2mg xalatan tubes
buy generic monograph – order pletal sale order cilostazol generic
feldene online order – rivastigmine 3mg drug purchase exelon without prescription
buy nootropil 800mg generic – buy levofloxacin pills for sale buy generic sinemet for sale
order hydrea without prescription – buy indinavir paypal order methocarbamol 500mg online cheap
buy depakote – cheap divalproex 500mg topiramate over the counter
order disopyramide phosphate online – epivir buy online chlorpromazine sale
cheap generic cytoxan – antivert for sale vastarel usa
aldactone medication – order dilantin 100mg sale how to get naltrexone without a prescription
order flexeril 15mg without prescription – flexeril 15mg usa buy generic enalapril online
order ondansetron 4mg for sale – selegiline order generic ropinirole 1mg
ascorbic acid cheap – cheap lopinavir ritonavir sale buy cheap generic prochlorperazine
purchase durex gel for sale – buy durex gel cheap zovirax us
rogaine without prescription – purchase finpecia order propecia online
buy generic leflunomide over the counter – cheap alfacalcidol for sale cartidin online buy
purchase tenormin – purchase betapace sale carvedilol 25mg ca
order calan 240mg sale – buy generic diltiazem online tenoretic over the counter
how to buy atorlip – buy bystolic pill buy bystolic 20mg online cheap
cheap lasuna sale – himcolin price buy himcolin without prescription
purchase gasex generic – cheap gasex sale diabecon drug
buy finax no prescription – cheap finasteride online brand uroxatral
buy speman no prescription – purchase speman generic cheap fincar
trileptal brand – pirfenidone without prescription synthroid 75mcg for sale
buy generic cyclosporine – buy methotrexate generic buy colchicine
buy generic lactulose for sale – purchase mentat sale order betahistine 16mg generic
calcort pills – buy cheap generic calcort generic brimonidine
neurontin 100mg us – brand sulfasalazine azulfidine price
buy generic besifloxacin over the counter – cost carbocisteine sildamax price
order celecoxib 200mg pills – urispas cheap brand indomethacin 75mg
benemid 500 mg tablet – buy etodolac pills order tegretol generic
cambia order online – aspirin 75mg brand aspirin 75 mg pill
buy colospa 135mg pills – order generic pletal pletal 100 mg generic
buy generic mestinon 60 mg – azathioprine 50mg sale azathioprine 25mg for sale
rumalaya pills – shallaki tablets order elavil generic
baclofen 10mg generic – feldene online order generic piroxicam
cost diclofenac – how to buy diclofenac buy cheap nimotop
buy cheap cyproheptadine – order cyproheptadine 4 mg online cheap buy generic tizanidine online
buy meloxicam 15mg online cheap – rizatriptan 5mg sale toradol 10mg pill
buy cefdinir 300mg pills – cleocin where to buy
buy artane for sale – buy artane medication voltaren gel purchase online
deltasone 10mg price – order deltasone sale permethrin where to buy
order isotretinoin 10mg generic – deltasone 20mg pills buy deltasone 20mg online
buy betamethasone generic – where can i buy differin monobenzone online order
where can i buy permethrin – benzoyl peroxide cheap tretinoin cream sale
order metronidazole without prescription – order metronidazole 200mg online cheap buy generic cenforce 50mg
buy clavulanate medication – levothroid buy online synthroid 100mcg oral
buy cheap hyzaar – purchase cephalexin for sale keflex 500mg cheap
generic clindamycin – buy clindamycin pill indocin 50mg generic
buy modafinil – order promethazine generic melatonin 3 mg cheap
purchase eurax without prescription – mupirocin where to buy aczone medication
xeloda 500mg brand – purchase danazol generic buy danocrine pills
order bupropion online – buy zyban 150 mg online cheap shuddha guggulu generic
progesterone 100mg price – buy clomiphene generic fertomid sale